Skip to main content

Considering Design Diversity

As a member of the SAIL Best Boats judging panel, I get to test sail a lot of the industry’s cutting-edge designs. From the latest production foiler to enormous yachts that are so tricked out a couple alone can handle them, the innovation each year is astounding. However, the newest ideas aren’t the only compelling topics in boat design. In fact, I often find the oldest ideas just as interesting, maybe even more so.

Sailing’s rich lineage can be followed back for millennia, and the diversity of design inspired by different environments has always fascinated me. The traditional dhow of Kenya, for example, is worlds apart from Norway’s nordland or Peru’s balsa. In India, the odam had wooden hulls that were sewn together before the advent of metal fasteners. The Inuit people lived too far north to have regular access to wood, so they built their umiaks from animal skins. In Zanzibar, the Swahili fishermen in the shallow Zanzibar Channel needed a boat that was stable with minimal draft, which gave rise to the outriggers on their ngalawas.

These ancient designs tell the stories of their people and the challenges their environments presented them with. And while none of them would best the Maxi-tri Edmond de Rothschild in a race around the world, they exhibit a level of tailored expertise almost unimaginable to the modern sailor. That’s what makes the Pacific Voyaging Society (see Pacific Voyages, p.22) and its contemporaries such exciting ventures. Even though the designs and materials aren’t entirely traditional, the desire to honor and reconnect with the past (not to mention campaign for a better future) is poignant and universally compelling. As for those seafaring communities with unbroken lines leading straight back to their ancestors, the idea of ancient wisdom guiding modern sailors is nothing short of enchanting.

In my mind, diversity—of both people and ideas—is as essential to the future of sailing as it was to the past. I, for one, love to see super-specialized, purpose-built boats that are really good at what they do, no matter how much they differ from what we’re used to. No designer will ever draw up “the ideal boat.” There are too many different sailors with too many different needs for any kind of one-size-fits-all solution, and good design responds to the needs of sailors. Which begs the question, if all these societies throughout history have been reflected in their boats, what stories do ours tell about us? 

December 2021



Charter: Lake Tahoe

A sail on Lake Tahoe has been on my bucket list since the day I first laid eyes on it, and come hell or high water, I decided I was going to someday charter a boat there. North America’s largest and deepest alpine lake, Tahoe sits at 6,225ft above sea level and straddles the more


Escape from New York Part 1

I was never supposed to take my boat through New York City. After getting sucked backward through the Cape Cod Canal on my way south from Maine, when the speed of the current exceeded the maximum speed of my little electric auxiliary, I wanted nothing to do with Hell Gate and more


A Watermaker Upgrade

As a classic-boat sailor, I’ve long held that simpler is the better. I still think this is true: a simpler boat is cheaper, she has less gadgets to break down and there’s a certain satisfaction in knowing you’re able to handle a bit of discomfort. Thus, for a long time, I sailed more


Sailing Speed Records

Although the 1903 defender of the America’s Cup, Reliance, was deemed a “racing freak”—the boat pushed design rules to their limit and couldn’t be beaten, at least in very specific conditions—designer Nat Herreshoff was nonetheless onto something. A century later, purpose-built more


Chartering with Non-sailors

Three tips on managing the madness First-time charterers and first-time sailors aren’t at all the same thing. One group may struggle with beginner chartering issues, like sailing a multihull, catching a mooring or dealing with base personnel. For the other group, though, more


A Gulf Stream Crossing at Night

Even the dome of light glowing above the city behind us had disappeared as if swallowed in a gulp by Noah’s whale. The moon was absent. Not a star twinkled overhead. The night was so dark we could have been floating in a pot of black ink. The only artificial lights to be seen more


Summer Sailing Programs

Every year, countless parents find themselves navigating the do’s and don’ts of enrolling their children in a summer learn-to-sail program for the first time. While the prospect of getting your kid on the water is exciting, as a sailing camp program director, there are a lot of more


Notice to Mariners: U.S.A! U.S.A! (Well, sorta…)

Some thoughts on a couple of recent developments on the U.S. racing scene that are more than a little at odds. To start with, congratulations to the US Sailing Team (USST) and its outstanding showing at the 53rd French Olympic Week regatta in Hyeres, France, with not one but more