We Predict the Winner

Will Alinghi’s catamaran, A5, or BMW/Oracle’s trimaran, BOR 90, be the faster boat in the 33rd America’s Cup Deed of Gift match? There are strong opinions on both sides.Despite the secrecy that is part of every America’s Cup, we used data collected on both boats by SAIL and then applied it to the Wolfson Unit’s velocity prediction programs (VPP), in particular the
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Will Alinghi’s catamaran, A5, or BMW/Oracle’s trimaran, BOR 90, be the faster boat in the 33rd America’s Cup Deed of Gift match? There are strong opinions on both sides.

Despite the secrecy that is part of every America’s Cup, we used data collected on both boats by SAIL and then applied it to the Wolfson Unit’s velocity prediction programs (VPP), in particular the WinDesign VPP developed in conjunction with Clay Oliver’s Yacht Research International.

Fig3.1_TwoHulls

Although the actual sailing weights of these boats are well guarded, weight is an integral part of the VPP analysis. For reference we scaled a C-Class catamaran, another class that has no weight restrictions, up to 90 feet. Interestingly, the estimated sailing weights for both A5 and BOR 90 compare favorably with the scaled up C-Class cat, even though the C–Class cat has just half the beam and sail area (Table 1). Although the estimated lighter weight of the powerful BOR 90 seems counterintuitive given the simpler two-hull platform of A5, the calculations show that this is indeed the case.

In fact, lighter weight is not necessarily an advantage upwind because weight provides stability and power to carry sail. However, water ballast, rumored to be used aboard both boats, will provide BOR 90 with added stability upwind, much like a crew trapezing from the windward hull of a C-Class. And when it is no longer needed, the water can be dumped, which moves the advantage back to the lighter boat.

Fig1_TwoHulls

We used boat geometry and the VPP’s internal hydrodynamic and aerodynamic models to derive baseline upwind speed polars for BOR 90 when sailing with water ballast in the windward ama (Figure 1). When true wind speeds go up to 14 knots—which is just below the 15-knot maximum allowed by the Notice of Race that existed in early December—the VPP suggests that BOR 90 can sail to windward at twice the true wind speed (TWS) and can reach velocity made good (Vmg) speeds that are about 50 percent higher than true wind speed.

Because of the shallow resistance curves and the strong link between boatspeed and apparent wind speed, the true-wind angle for the optimum Vmg—represented by the top of the curves—is not well defined and the apparent-wind angle hardly changes as the boat bears away and accelerates. This means that the performance potential for both boats will depend on how well each team has learned its boat’s optimum sailing angle for a given wind strength.

Our analysis using BOR 90’s soft-sail rig shows her flying a hull in just 8 knots of true windspeed, even when she is carrying water ballast. Above that windspeed, the VPP controls the sail forces to limit heeling moment, which means the crew will have to control the sails very carefully to keep BOR 90 on its feet. An interesting comparison comes from the 32nd Cup match, which was also sailed off Valencia, but in monohulls. When true wind reached 9 knots, those crews also had to start controlling their sails’ power. But in that case they wanted to optimize sail efficiency rather than limit heel angle, because unlike a multihull, the righting moment kept increasing with heel.

Apparent wind angles for both these boats are remarkably similar across a wide range of wind speeds and true-wind angles, because once they bear away, they sail so fast that their apparent wind is always well forward. For BOR 90, predicted apparent wind angles vary between 14 and 16 degrees, which makes it very close-winded. This is another interesting contrast with the America’s Cup Class monohulls that sailed with apparent-wind angles of around 17 degrees. Although both multihulls do sail upwind at narrow apparent-wind angles, their optimum upwind true angles of 40–45 degrees are relatively wide compared to a monohull because their boatspeeds are so much higher relative to true-wind speed: In other words, foot fast upwind rather than point higher and go slower.

Once a baseline performance is established, the VPP can assess other differences between boats. If, for example, A5 really is heavier than BOR 90, can it sail successfully upwind against BOR 90 without water ballast while BOR 90 sails with water ballast?

In 8 knots TWS, the VPP shows BOR 90 sailing on its leeward ama and the catamaran flying a hull. Because both are sailing with the same weight, they have similar drag, but BOR 90 should have an advantage of 5–10 seconds a mile because the increased water ballast converts directly into power and speed. A5 can also add water ballast, but since BOR 90 can add more (it has three hulls, not two) it should maintain a relative advantage. In seven knots of true-wind speed, performance is not limited by stability and BOR 90 can sail without water ballast and still fly a hull when A5 may not be able to do so.


Downwind

Fig2_TwoHulls

The predictions for BOR 90 in Figure 2 show that optimum downwind Vmg speeds, with a Code O, come at apparent wind angles of 22–28 degrees. (The VPP can account for the improved lift generated by a Code O type of sail used at narrow angles.) Because of its sail area and ability to fly a hull downwind in 7 knots true, BOR 90 might be as much as 20 seconds/mile faster than A5 in 8 knots of true wind. This advantage disappears at 12 knots true, and in higher windspeeds A5 appears to be quicker. However, BOR 90 can regain an advantage of 5 to 10 seconds a mile by adding water ballast. Just as in the upwind mode, whenever A5 adds water BOR 90 can add more. So anytime these boats are flying a hull, upwind or down, the VPP gives the advantage to BOR 90.

Fig4_TwoHulls

Even though the two reaching legs used on the 39-mile triangular course required for the second race will be a little tighter than the optimum downwind gybing angles used for the 20-mile windward-leeward courses called for in the first and third races, BOR 90 should retain the power and speed advantage similar to that established for the downwind Vmg.

Because both boats will be flying a hull in most conditions, there will also be some aerodynamic differences. For example, even though there is additional windage from BOR 90’s amas—representing a loss of about 0.5 seconds/mile—the main hull also acts as a seal between the sails and the ocean, a feature that A5 does not have. This loss of seal can be simulated in the VPP by reducing the span of A5’s rig. A redution of just three feet can make a speed difference of up to 5 seconds/mile, or 1.5 minutes on a windward leg. Both boats are so close winded that their rigs can produce the very high efficiencies that come from having large spans.

BOR 90’s wing mast and solid sail has less sail area than its soft sail, but it is reportedly much more efficient, especially in light airs. It is also reported to be able to quickly produce more camber coming out of a tack and that can help it to fly a hull more quickly. Downwind, a wing mast can produce more lift than a soft sail, although with no sail area restrictions, both teams can use large Code O headsails. In fact, A5 has reportedly increased its bowsprit to accommodate larger downwind sails.

Fig5_TwoHulls

The basis for these predictions could be wrong, of course, and with boats as large, powerful and complex as these two are, anything can happen. But if the engineers and builders have done their job and the BOR 90 team can keep the rig in the boat and avoid other structural breakdowns, they stand to prevail over A5, and possibly by a considerable margin.

Related

Beneyteau-Excess12

Boat Review: Excess 12

Groupe Beneteau, builder of Lagoon catamarans, has introduced a new multihull line called Excess. The first of the boats to reach U.S. shores at the Annapolis boat show was the Excess 12, a 38ft 6in design based on the popular Lagoon 40. The thought process behind this new boat ...read more

Spindriftracing

Extreme Sailing: No Piece of Cake

It can be easy to take for granted the incredible performance of today’s most cutting-edge grand prix racing boats. The latest crop of full-foiling 75ft America’s Cup monohulls, for example, were all up on their foils and even successfully tacking within hours of their first ...read more

Solar-Dinghy-pump-photo

Gear: Solar Powered Dinghy Pump

Tired of forever finding your dinghy or open daysailer filled with water when you arrive to go sailing? For years, sailors and engineers have sought a solution to this seemingly eternal problem, and now it appears the folks at Sea Joule Marine may have finally found it in their ...read more

BestBoatPromo-03

Best Boats 2020

How’s this for a thought experiment: imagine setting a diminutive Tiwal 2 inflatable dinghy alongside a Catalina 545 cruiser? It would be hard to imagine two more different watercraft, and yet they are both still very much sailboats. They are also both winners in this year’s ...read more

Hanse-675

Video Tour: Hanse 675

This past fall at the Annapolis Sailboat show, we had a chance to catch up with Hanse’s  Maxim Neumann, who kindly provided us a tour of the company’s new flagship, the Hanse 675. An impressive, well-built production yacht that boldly ventures into maxi-yacht territory, the ...read more

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell. Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com Be thrifty with propane  If you like to cook on board, the propane tanks supplied as standard with many modern yachts won’t get you far. Whether we bake bread or not, the one thing we all do is boil ...read more

xBOM2019_Loris-von_Siiebenthal01588.jpg.pagespeed.ic.MhB0Vm5anP

Mirabau Photo Contest Winners

Swiss photographer Loris von Siebenthal has been named winner of the Mirabaud Yacht Racing Image photo competition for 2019. Von Siebenthal bested no less than 133 other photographers from 29 countries submitting shots of everything from regular weekend regattas to junior ...read more