Oracle wins court battle

When a final-arbiter court in April ruled 6-0 against Alinghi’s artificially inseminated Spanish challenger, the mantle of Challenger of Record for the next America’s Cup match passed to Larry Ellison’s American team, BMW Oracle Racing/Golden Gate Yacht Club. Thus passed two years of wrangling and climbing through the highest courts of New York, where the America’s Cup Deed of Gift was
Author:
Publish date:
Updated on

When a final-arbiter court in April ruled 6-0 against Alinghi’s artificially inseminated Spanish challenger, the mantle of Challenger of Record for the next America’s Cup match passed to Larry Ellison’s American team, BMW Oracle Racing/Golden Gate Yacht Club. Thus passed two years of wrangling and climbing through the highest courts of New York, where the America’s Cup Deed of Gift was incorporated in 1877.

americas_cup_alinghi

Only an established yacht club may challenge for the Cup. Club Nautico Espaol de Vela, hastily thrown together inside the Cup village in Valencia (apparently under tutelage of the defender, Ernesto Bertarelli’s Alinghi/ La Socit Nautique de Genve) was ruled illegitimate. The outcome followed a cycle of rulings in favor of BMW Oracle, followed by a lower-appellate ruling in favor of Alinghi, followed by this ultimate reversal by the New York State Court of Appeals.

In hindsight, Alinghi overreached in creating a protocol assigning unprecedented powers and control to the defender, terms that only a “lapdog” challenger would have accepted. Available arguments were many, but the final ruling turned upon a narrow point.

Consider the meaning of the word “having,” as in the phrasing of the Deed of Gift, which limits a challenger to an organization, “having for its annual regatta an ocean water course on the sea, or an arm of the sea.” Ellison’s attorneys contended, that an organization formed with the intent of someday staging a race does not fulfill the meaning of “having”.

What next? The outside-your-box challenge that Ellison filed in July, 2007, naming a 90-foot multihull, was legitimized. But Ellison’s publicly stated aim was to force Bertarelli to renegotiate toward a more-balanced format. Ellison’s 90-foot trimaran (a second version has been rumored) was built as a hammer, he said, leaving all possibilities open. Soon after the court ruling, the commodores of all previous Cup-winning clubs published a letter urging compromise. And that, as we went to press, was the state of play.

Related

Meridian-X-Spin_2

MOB: A Whistle in the Wind

Mark Wheeler went overboard a few minutes before midnight. He was in the middle of Lake Michigan, 30 miles offshore in 40 knots of wind. As he fumbled for the lanyard to inflate his lifejacket he watched his racing sailboat, Meridian X, disappear into the night at more than 18 ...read more

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell. Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com Slapper stopper  When I came on deck at 0800 to hoist my colors on a visitors’ mooring recently, there was an awkward slop running in. This doesn’t trouble my Mason 44, which has a traditional counter ...read more

Tilly-1

Gear: Tilley Polaris Hat

A True Blue Tilley Sailing is all about fun in the sun, but it sometimes doesn’t take long to get too much of a good thing, especially when on a prolonged cruise or offshore passage. Enter the Tilley Polaris, the latest lid developed by iconic Canadian hat-maker Tilley. ...read more

Sand-TOWEL_MODEL-3

CGear Sand-Free Beach Towel

Sand Be Gone! The summer is hot and full of terrors—not the least of which is the sand that sticks in your beach towel in the hopes of a free ride back to your car or boat. Fortunately, there's now the CGear Sand-Free Beach Towel, engineered in polyester to not only dry quickly ...read more

01-Blowup-Tiwal2_sailing-(3)

Gear: Tiwal Inflatable Sailing Dinghy

Blow-up Boating A few years ago, the French company Tiwal arrived on U.S. shores with that most improbable of products, an inflatable sailing dinghy that actually sails the way a boat is supposed to. Now, nearly 1,000 Tiwal 3’s later, the company is back with its Tiwal 2, an ...read more

Koozy

Gear: 22 Below Koozie

Killer Koozie For all that sailors love the warmth of this time of year, that same warmth can also wreak havoc on their otherwise icy-cold beers. (Unless, of course, you drink them very, very fast. But we won’t go there.) To help deal with this terrible hardship, North ...read more

Cool-Specs

Gear: Gill's Race Fusion Sunglasses

Wicked Cool Specs Is there anything in the world of sailing more fun than a cool pair of shades? Heck, no! And it would hard to find a cooler pair than these new Race Fusion specs from longtime weather-gear manufacture Gill. In addition to looking great, they include a number of ...read more

North_new

Gear: North Sails Waterproof Pack

A few years ago, North Sails made a big push into the apparel business with all kinds of sharp-looking button-down shirts, shorts and fleeces. That doesn’t mean, though, that the North Sails Collection isn’t still plenty practical, as is evident in its new roll-over waterproof ...read more