Oracle wins court battle

When a final-arbiter court in April ruled 6-0 against Alinghi’s artificially inseminated Spanish challenger, the mantle of Challenger of Record for the next America’s Cup match passed to Larry Ellison’s American team, BMW Oracle Racing/Golden Gate Yacht Club. Thus passed two years of wrangling and climbing through the highest courts of New York, where the America’s Cup Deed of Gift was
Author:
Publish date:

When a final-arbiter court in April ruled 6-0 against Alinghi’s artificially inseminated Spanish challenger, the mantle of Challenger of Record for the next America’s Cup match passed to Larry Ellison’s American team, BMW Oracle Racing/Golden Gate Yacht Club. Thus passed two years of wrangling and climbing through the highest courts of New York, where the America’s Cup Deed of Gift was incorporated in 1877.

americas_cup_alinghi

Only an established yacht club may challenge for the Cup. Club Nautico Espaol de Vela, hastily thrown together inside the Cup village in Valencia (apparently under tutelage of the defender, Ernesto Bertarelli’s Alinghi/ La Socit Nautique de Genve) was ruled illegitimate. The outcome followed a cycle of rulings in favor of BMW Oracle, followed by a lower-appellate ruling in favor of Alinghi, followed by this ultimate reversal by the New York State Court of Appeals.

In hindsight, Alinghi overreached in creating a protocol assigning unprecedented powers and control to the defender, terms that only a “lapdog” challenger would have accepted. Available arguments were many, but the final ruling turned upon a narrow point.

Consider the meaning of the word “having,” as in the phrasing of the Deed of Gift, which limits a challenger to an organization, “having for its annual regatta an ocean water course on the sea, or an arm of the sea.” Ellison’s attorneys contended, that an organization formed with the intent of someday staging a race does not fulfill the meaning of “having”.

What next? The outside-your-box challenge that Ellison filed in July, 2007, naming a 90-foot multihull, was legitimized. But Ellison’s publicly stated aim was to force Bertarelli to renegotiate toward a more-balanced format. Ellison’s 90-foot trimaran (a second version has been rumored) was built as a hammer, he said, leaving all possibilities open. Soon after the court ruling, the commodores of all previous Cup-winning clubs published a letter urging compromise. And that, as we went to press, was the state of play.

Related

albintoilet

Gear: Albin Pump Marine Toilet

Head Start Is there room for a new marine toilet? Albin Pump Marine thinks so, having just introduced its line of Swedish-built heads—ranging from compact to full-size models—to the American market. The toilets feature vitreous porcelain bowls and either wooden or thermoplastic ...read more

07n_45R2699

Multihull Sailor: Classic Cats

If you’re looking for a decent sub-40ft cruising cat, you have few choices when it comes to new-boat offerings. It is a well-known fact that the multihull market has taken off in a way very few could have predicted. Despite Hurricane Irma’s recent destruction of a large part of ...read more

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell. Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com Thanks a bunch  This scene is very calm and seamanlike. No frantic rope throwing or shouting. As he passes the line to the gent on the dock, the crew on the boat says, quietly and clearly, “Would you ...read more

mcarthy-and-mouse

Experience: McCarthy and the Mouse

Sitting at the helm in a light breeze, my arms crusted with a fine rime of salt, my skin so dry I’d lost my fingerprints, I heard a clatter and a curse from below. There were only three of us a thousand miles from shore and only one on watch at a time. Usually, the off watch lay ...read more

2018-giftGuide

2018 Holiday Gift Guide

Brass Yacht Lamp Does someone on your gift list spend the whole winter missing the warm days on the water? Let them bring a little bit of nautical atmosphere home with this new lamp from Weems & Plath. The glass enclosure means the flame cannot be blown out even by ...read more

image001

Opinion: On Not Giving Up Sailing

E.B. White was 64 when he wrote his now-famous essay “The Sea and the Wind That Blows,” which begins as a romantic paean to sailing and then drifts, as if spun around by a pessimistic eddy of thought, into a reflection on selling his boat. Does an aging sailor quit while he’s ...read more

1812-JeanneaueNewsVideo

Jeanneau Sun Odyssey 410

Designed by Marc Lombard, the Sun Odyssey 410 shares much in common with her older siblings including of course, the walk-around deck. Other features that set the 410 apart from other models being introduced this year include the 410’s “negative bow” shape allowing for a longer ...read more