Updated:
Original:

Oracle wins court battle

When a final-arbiter court in April ruled 6-0 against Alinghi’s artificially inseminated Spanish challenger, the mantle of Challenger of Record for the next America’s Cup match passed to Larry Ellison’s American team, BMW Oracle Racing/Golden Gate Yacht Club. Thus passed two years of wrangling and climbing through the highest courts of New York, where the America’s Cup Deed of Gift was
Author:

When a final-arbiter court in April ruled 6-0 against Alinghi’s artificially inseminated Spanish challenger, the mantle of Challenger of Record for the next America’s Cup match passed to Larry Ellison’s American team, BMW Oracle Racing/Golden Gate Yacht Club. Thus passed two years of wrangling and climbing through the highest courts of New York, where the America’s Cup Deed of Gift was incorporated in 1877.

Only an established yacht club may challenge for the Cup. Club Nautico Espaol de Vela, hastily thrown together inside the Cup village in Valencia (apparently under tutelage of the defender, Ernesto Bertarelli’s Alinghi/ La Socit Nautique de Genve) was ruled illegitimate. The outcome followed a cycle of rulings in favor of BMW Oracle, followed by a lower-appellate ruling in favor of Alinghi, followed by this ultimate reversal by the New York State Court of Appeals.

In hindsight, Alinghi overreached in creating a protocol assigning unprecedented powers and control to the defender, terms that only a “lapdog” challenger would have accepted. Available arguments were many, but the final ruling turned upon a narrow point.

Consider the meaning of the word “having,” as in the phrasing of the Deed of Gift, which limits a challenger to an organization, “having for its annual regatta an ocean water course on the sea, or an arm of the sea.” Ellison’s attorneys contended, that an organization formed with the intent of someday staging a race does not fulfill the meaning of “having”.

What next? The outside-your-box challenge that Ellison filed in July, 2007, naming a 90-foot multihull, was legitimized. But Ellison’s publicly stated aim was to force Bertarelli to renegotiate toward a more-balanced format. Ellison’s 90-foot trimaran (a second version has been rumored) was built as a hammer, he said, leaving all possibilities open. Soon after the court ruling, the commodores of all previous Cup-winning clubs published a letter urging compromise. And that, as we went to press, was the state of play.

Related

03-IMG_0590

Bill Tilman’s Simple Sailing

Like an ostrich on a bad day, I’m head-down in the lazarette of Nellie, my Beneteau First 42, dealing with the propane tank. My wife taps me on the shoulder, and I rise to see a pair of foiling catamarans accelerating onto their carbon-fiber wings. As the blood drains from my ...read more

01-LEAD-210801_PM_Tokyo20_22825_5540

Olympic Sailing: Where to Now?

It’s official, not only is the United States no longer an Olympic power when it comes to sailing, it’s fast beginnings look like an also-ran—albeit an also-ran with loads of potential. What other conclusion is there to draw from the fact that for the second time in three ...read more

244526945_394104495768313_1401658800642145082_n

Return of the Annapolis Boat Show

After a hiatus in 2020, the United States Boat Show in Annapolis, Maryland returned in full force last weekend. “Pent up demand” was the name of the game for visitors and exhibitors alike. Queues to get in each morning stretched around the block, and the docks were congested ...read more

Untitled-1

Sailing Hall of Fame Inducts Class of 2021

This weekend, the National Sailing Hall of Fame has inducted eleven new members to make up the class of 2021. “The remarkable achievements of this year’s class exemplify excellence and an unwavering dedication to our sport,” said National Sailing Hall of Fame president Gus ...read more

ed3b8ae9-b65d-2941-47ec-cd0277bfcbe8

Mirabaud Voting Open to the Public

Photos from the industry's top photographers are in, and the 12th annual Mirabaud Yacht Racing Image competition is underway. An international panel of judges has selected this year's 80 finalists, which have been published online. The panel will also select the winner of the ...read more

P1320232-copy

Annapolis’ Boat Show is Back

After a year off in 2020, the United States Boat Show in Annapolis is back. From the diminutive Areys Pond Cat 14 XFC to the massive Lagoon Sixty 5, many of the SAIL’s 2022 Best Boats Nominees are on display for the public to get a firsthand look at, and SAIL’s Best Boats panel ...read more

05-Squall-in-the-ITCZ

Close-Hauled to Hawaii

The saying “Nothing goes to windward like a 747,” is one of my favorites. I actually once took a 747 upwind, retracing my earlier downwind sailing route across the Pacific. I’ve also done a fair bit of ocean sailing to windward. The 747 was a lot more comfortable. But then ...read more

01-LEAD-IMG-2106

Refurbishing Shirley Rose: Part 3

If you missed the first installment, click here. The hull and deck of Shirley Rose had been repaired, but what kind of sailboat would she be without a sturdy rig? I was told she was ready to sail, and that the owner replaced the standing rigging a few years before. Shirley Rose ...read more