Skip to main content
Updated:
Original:

Legal Headaches

Am I the only one who gets a headache when I hear the words “America’s Cup” coupled with the word “court”? I highly doubt it, especially given the massive success that was the 32nd Cup, and the resounding flop that has thus far been the experience of the 33rd Cup’s pre-dance ritual. Today’s head banger is compliments of the Socit Nautique de Genve (SNG) and Alinghi, who proposed
Author:

Am I the only one who gets a headache when I hear the words “America’s Cup” coupled with the word “court”? I highly doubt it, especially given the massive success that was the 32nd Cup, and the resounding flop that has thus far been the experience of the 33rd Cup’s pre-dance ritual.

Today’s head banger is compliments of the Socit Nautique de Genve (SNG) and Alinghi, who proposed yesterday to file an immediate appeal with the New York Appellate Court with the hopes of “accelerating” the legal wrangling that has become the 33rd Cup. For those who are a day or so behind in their Aspirin intake, the point that is being hotly contended in the courtroom is the “when” regarding the 33rd Cup. Since this next match will be a Deed of Gift Match (DGM), the Deed of Gift itself states that the DGM must take place ten months after a decision has been reached to race the next Cup as a DGC. (Confused yet?)

In essence, the trouble stems from the question as to when this ten-month timeframe began. Judge Cahn originally handed down a decision in late November of 2007 stating that the next Cup would be a DGM between the Challenger of Record, the Golden Gate Yacht Club, and the Defender, the Socit Nautique de Genve (SNG), which he upheld in March of 2008 following a previous appeal by the Socit Nautique de Genve, thus starting the countdown. BMW Oracle offered “tolling” rights to Alinghi in front of Justice Cahn following the November decision and the impending appeal, meaning that the ten-month period would not start until Justice Cahn ruled on Alinghi’s appeal. Alinghi passed on this offer, and now, since Justice Cahn upheld his previous decision, time is running out for Alinghi to design, build, and train on the 90-foot by 90-foot catamarans, which will be the class for the next Cup.

Predictably, both the Socit Nautique de Genve (SNG) and the Golden Gate Yacht Club/BMW Oracle Racing’s PR machines have been at it at full force, rifling off press releases arguing their side’s point.

Says SNG and Alinghi: “The intransigency of Golden Gate Yacht Club (GGYC) since the day they filed their law suit has forced SNG to move the case to the next level in the New York legal system. In an attempt to obtain a swift resolution to the current uncertainty, an expedited process is being requested together with a motion to stay the case, this in order to suspend the implementation of Justice Cahn’s previous order until the Appellate Court rules.”

Says BMW Oracle: “The Golden Gate Yacht Club (GGYC) said
today that further legal attempts by the defender to delay the next America’s Cup Deed of Gift match are regrettable and the club will be doing everything it can to ensure the event remains on track.”

Hopefully, the legal wrangling will soon give way to good, clean sailing grudge match, as the office supply of Aspirin is running low and should be reserved for combating hangovers, not legal hang-ups.

Posted: April 15, 2008

Related

SailingAwards

VIDEO: World Sailing Awards 2021

Alec Wilkinson and Hannah White host the World Sailing Awards and announce the Rolex World Sailor of the Year and 11th Hour Racing Sustainability Award.  December 2021 ...read more

02-RV-WHY

Cruising: Miracle On Ice

I was preparing some tea just before heading topside for my watch. Even though it was summertime, the tea was not iced—it was hot. That’s because our boat was in the High Arctic. We were trying to complete a westbound transit of the treacherous Northwest Passage. If we ...read more

Hanse_460_Bilder_Web_Exterior_0003-promo

New Monohulls: Hallberg-Rassy 400 & Hanse 460

For all the consolidation in the boatbuilding world in recent years, there remains plenty of variety out there, as can be seen in these two new monohulls. The products of two very different boatbuilders offer two very different takes on performance-cruising, even as they also ...read more

Waterlines

The Power of Sails

I suppose it isn’t merely a coincidence that I’ve made significant changes to the sailplans of the last three cruising boats I’ve owned. The first project was the biggest. My old Golden Hind 31, Sophie, had lots of charm and character, but her sloop rig was laughably small. ...read more

01-LEAD-BahiaCobre

Charter the Sea of Cortez

Chartering and the notion of going “off the beaten path” may sound self-contradictory. Charter companies tend to put bases where demand is high and they can turn a profit, so if you’re lucky enough to find an outfit and a destination that gets away from the typical—say yes. To ...read more

22D6FB6F-AA49-4784-A3A8-960F5A7CE330

Cruising: Anchoring Skills

Watching charterers make a run for the last mooring in a cove is fun—and weird. I always wonder why so many would rather try to catch a mooring than drop the hook. Maybe charterers don’t trust their anchoring skills, but it’s harder to drive up and grab a buoy than most people ...read more

BD-TJV21_Malama_063

11th Hour Breakdown in the TJV

11th Hour Racing’s Mālama kicked off the second week of the Transat Jaques Vabre with keel problems, forcing co-skippers Charlie Enright and Pascal Bidégorry to adjust for a more conservative approach to the race’s remaining 2000 miles. “We’ve been dealing with a lot of ...read more

2021-rolex-y-of-y-email-graphic

Rolex Nominations Open

Award season is upon us, and US Sailing is looking for the next Yachtsman and Yachtswoman of the Year. Established in 1961 by US Sailing and sponsored by Rolex since 1980, the annual Rolex Yachtsman and Yachtswoman of the Year awards recognize individual male and female sailors ...read more