Sailboat Centerboard Upgrade - Sail Magazine

Sailboat Centerboard Upgrade

Using a popular airfoil analysis code (XFOIL, by M. Drela & H. Youngren, see http://web.mit.edu/drela/Public/xfoil/) we analyzed the performance of the stock centerboard of a San Juan 23. As this board was a thin flat plate, this performance was rather poor, consistent with the
Author:
Publish date:

Using a popular airfoil analysis code (XFOIL, by M. Drela & H. Youngren, see http://web.mit.edu/drela/Public/xfoil/) we analyzed the performance of the stock centerboard of a San Juan 23. As this board was a thin flat plate, this performance was rather poor, consistent with the excessive leeway (115? tacking angles) and noticeable lee helm of the vessel. A thicker, more effective centerboard would not fit the narrow centerboard slot of the vessel. However, again using XFOIL, we developed an add-on leading edge for the stock board, which greatly improved the upwind performance (95? tacking angles). Having the add-on leading edge remain outside the slot when the board was raised, allowed that edge to be thicker than the board. As shown in Figure 1, the leading edge is elliptical, making the resultant centerboard cross section tadpole-like.

We present here selected XFOIL results for the stock centerboard, a NACA 0010 cross-section, and the tadpole cross-section. The first three figures show pressure coefficient data for a 6? angle of attack and a Reynolds number corresponding to 5 knots. These figures also reflect forced transition to turbulent boundary layers at 5% of chord (1% for the stock case). Both the NACA and tadpole cross-sections perform well with either forced or computed boundary transition. Forced transition merely reflects the reality of non-polished board surfaces. For the stock board, however, it is only by such measures that the board is not completely stalled at more than a 3? angle of attack.

saip_0910_01_z+sailboat_centerboard_upgrade+modified
saip_0910_02_z+sailboat_centerboard_upgrade+xfoil_graph
saip_0910_03_z+sailboat_centerboard_upgrade+naca
saip_0910_04_z+sailboat_centerboard_upgrade+cross_section

Figures 4 and 5 present lift and drag data for the three cross-sections, again assuming 5 knots and forced transitions.

As shown by Figures 5 and 6, the tadpole cross-section significantly outperforms the stock flat plate and nearly equals the performance of the NACA0010 section.

saip_0910_05_z+sailboat_centerboard_upgrade+lift_coefficient
saip_0910_06_z+sailboat_centerboard_upgrade+drag_coefficient

Related

Outremer45

Boat Review: Outremer 45

It’s funny the way things that work right almost inevitably tend to look right as well. Case in point: the Outremer 45, a catamaran that can’t help but turn heads with its large rig, nicely sculpted cabintrunk and narrow, purposeful bows. Better yet, under sail the boat more than ...read more

Sunset-Tyrrel-Bay

Charter: Glorious Grenada

In the wake of the hurricanes that devastated the Virgin Islands last year many charterers ended up going farther south to Grenada and the Grenadines where they found the sailing excellent and the vibe just fine“God must have been a sailor when he created the Caribbean,” a friend ...read more

WaterLinesNov

Waterlines: Tangled Up in Pots

I learned to sail on the Maine coast as a boy, and one of the things my elders taught me was to respect fishing gear. If you got caught up with a lobster pot, you did everything you could to get clear without cutting the pot warp. It represented a family’s livelihood and thus was ...read more

7353

Harken’s Reflex 3 top-down Furler

Furl PowerAre you afraid of flying—spinnakers, that is? Harken’s new Reflex 3 top-down furler will tame A-sails on monohulls from 44-58ft and multis from 39-55ft, and Code 0’s on 39-54ft monos and 36-50ft multis. All you do is heave on the furling line and the sail will roll up ...read more

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell.Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.comDitch the stress Owners of high-freeboard yachts best boarded via the stern sugar-scoop like to back them into a slip, but the process can be fraught on a windy day or when there’s a current running, ...read more

Sun-Odyssey-490-Bertrand_DUQUENNE-aft

Boat Review: Jeanneau Sun Odyssey 490

True innovation in monohull sailboat design can be a bit elusive these days. That’s not to say that there are no more new ideas, but it does seem that many new tweaks and introductions are a bit incremental: let’s say evolutionary rather than revolutionary. Just when it seems ...read more