DIY: a Top-to-Bottom Refit

Author:
Updated:
Original:
Passion after her relaunch

Passion after her relaunch

I found my sailing “dream boat” in the spring of 1979 while racing on Lake St. Clair in Michigan. Everyone had heard about the hot new boat in town, and we were anxiously awaiting the appearance of this new Pearson 40. She made it to the starting line just before the race started and sailed by in a good breeze with a bone in her teeth. I was blown away. In my eyes, she was stunning. At that moment I told myself, “That is my dream boat.” It took 20 years, but the stars finally aligned, and I bought my Pearson 40 in 1999 and renamed her Passion.

The boat was pretty rough cosmetically, but my primary concern was the condition of her hull, deck, rigging and systems. I knew I could bring her looks back, but did not want to find out after buying her that she had major structural issues or wet balsa core problems that would make a refit unreasonably difficult. So, before writing the check, I enlisted the services of an expert marine surveyor to do an in-depth analysis of her condition, with an emphasis on moisture content, delamination and structural integrity. We spent hours tapping, exploring and testing, and in the end I received, not surprisingly, a combination of both good news and bad news. The good news was that structurally she was in very good shape, with only two small areas of wet balsa core and no delamination. The bad news included a bad case of bottom blisters, old outdated wiring, a contaminated fuel tank and aging hoses that needed replacement. Most of the running and standing rigging also needed to be replaced.

The original saloon (inset) and how she looks after the refit

The original saloon (inset) and how she looks after the refit

PATIENCE IS A VIRTUE

After the price was adjusted to compensate for all of this, Passion was mine, not yet a true “dream boat” but a solid platform on which I could rebuild. Of course, at this point, I could have started tearing the boat apart immediately to begin the refit. But instead, I decided to sail her for a few years to better learn exactly what she needed, where she had problems and what I wanted to change. Those four years also allowed me to attend a few boat shows to look for new ideas and equipment.

Looking back on it now, there is no question that was one of the best decisions I could have made, and I would recommend anyone else planning to buy and refit their dream cruising boat do the same. Not surprisingly, after sailing Passion I had a long list of stuff I wanted to change, including a number of things I would never have otherwise considered—including a nav-station reconfiguration, greater fuel capacity, improved and expanded storage, a reduction in the number of berths, a better icebox, improved rudder design and dramatically improved access to the engine and systems to ease maintenance hassles. Finally, with those four solid years of sailing behind me, I started in on rebuilding my dream boat in 2004.

THE OCD FACTOR

Without a doubt one of the worst things that can happen when refitting/rebuilding an older boat is that you develop a kind of marine “obsessive-compulsive disorder” (OCD). I say this because I have it. Specifically, my marine OCD requires perfection when “good enough” will do, thereby forcing me to spend untold hours and brain power planning every detail. OCD means every bit of paint or varnish must be exceptional. OCD also caused me to spend a lot of time (and money!) making sure every piece of hardware or equipment was top-of-the-line, new or refurbished, and perfectly installed. That said, my marine OCD also now allows me to bring my 40-year-old boat into a marina and have people start asking questions like “is that a new boat?” or making comments like, “Wow, my wife thinks yours is the most beautiful boat in the marina.”

Standards aside, another important step I took when I started the rebuild was renting a 3,000ft industrial warehouse with a side yard where I could put the boat while she was under repair. I also modified the 600ft office inside the warehouse into an apartment by adding a shower and kitchen sink, which allowed me to live within a few steps of my project. I called this property the “warehome.” Technically it was a violation of the certificate of occupancy, but I won’t tell if you won’t. The back 2,400ft of my warehome provided an open workspace for large parts fabrication, a simple and paint booth, and storage space for my tools and all the equipment and parts removed from the boat during the refit, not to mention an extensive selection of wood, fiberglass, coatings and other materials.

In the end, this setup allowed me to efficiently work on the boat with few wasted steps. It also allowed me the room to properly organize everything from the raw materials to components and gear removed from the boat. I cannot overemphasize how important this degree of organization was to the success of the project. As an example, there are over 300 separate pieces of mahogany trim throughout the boat, and I had nearly 100 spools of marine grade wire of all gauges and colors. Overall, I estimate there were more than 2,500 individual items used to complete the rebuild. It would have been impossible to manage that number of items without good organization. I went so far as to list everything removed from the boat on a spreadsheet. Marine OCD strikes again!

DCP_1697

IN FOR THE LONG HAUL

Next, I worked with a boat hauler to truck the boat from the marina to the warehome, where I had her craned into her temporary home. Prior to shipping her I also purchased eight Brownell boat stands and had a welder build two steel pedestals to set her on, as opposed to using wood blocks.

Once Passion was sitting in the yard, the work began in earnest. I started with a modest 3- to 5-year plan, but my OCD promptly took control, and the job very quickly mushroomed into a total rebuild that included removing and replacing all systems (engine, electrical, plumbing and propane); replacing the water, fuel and holding tanks; repainting the hull and deck; and completely reconfiguring and refinishing the interior. The actual amount of time spent working on the boat I estimate to be about five to six years, but due to several job-based interruptions where the boat sat for extended periods without being touched, the total calendar time was 14 years. Insane? Probably, but I had to get it right.

Ed Note: Sadly, Chip passed away aboard his beloved Passion shortly after this story went to press. Chip was a fine sailor, a great person to work with and we at SAIL will miss him.

March 2019

Related

NewportBoatShow

Newport International Boat Show Announces Dates

This year marks half a century for New England’s largest boat show, and the celebration will be in person. In a statement released yesterday, Nancy Piffard, Show Director of Newport Exhibition Group said, “We are excited to kick off the boat show season in-person this year… We ...read more

Screen-Shot-2021-03-03-at-9.48.03-AM

World Sailing Trust Launches Global Participation Study

Two years after its global survey on women in sailing, the World Sailing Trust is surveying the entire sport in order to assess equity, diversity and inclusion. The survey will be conducted bi-annually to monitor trends and progress. "By researching the sport, the aim is to ...read more

01A-LEAD-Finished-table

DIY: A Better Saloon Table

The original saloon table in my Down East 45 schooner was a single heavy sheet of 3/4in laminated plywood, 27in wide by 57in long. It was supported on two substantial aluminum pedestals locking into a set of large round collars screwed to the sole. There were two annoying ...read more

02b-screen-shot

Salty Dawgs Recognized by CCA

The Salty Dawg Sailing Association (SDSA) has long been the go-to organization for high value, affordable rallies, but when Covid forced the sudden closure of borders in the Caribbean, it pivoted to organizing the Homeward Bound Flotilla. Its experience organizing rallies came ...read more

FB-BHM-1024

SAIL Black History Month Series: James Forten

James Forten was born on September 2, 1766 in Philadelphia to free Black parents Thomas and Margaret Forten. Forten attended a Quaker school as a young child, then went to work with his father who was a sailmaker. His father died when he was still young, and Forten worked ...read more

sailme-app_ SAIL

5 Ways Sail.me Helps You Monetize Your Boat

Ready to earn some extra funds by renting out your boat or yacht? Sail.me is an interactive service that allows you to monetize your boat in a secure, safe, and easy way. A user-friendly app and website will help you manage reservations, add-ons, and set customized routes to ...read more

VendeePromo

2020-21 Vendée Timeline

As a spectator event, France’s Vendée Globe never disappoints, and the 2020-21 edition of the quadrennial round-the-world race was no exception. From equipment failures to climactic rescues, heartbreaking abandonments and a breathtakingly close finish, this edition, which ...read more

valleytrunk3

BVI Chartering in the Pandemic

The week before I flew out to the British Virgin Islands for a bareboat charter, I was having a few second thoughts. The islands had broken out of their Covid-enforced tourism hiatus in December, but the conditions of entry seemed a little stringent: a negative Covid test within ...read more