Busted!

Sailors have been tying knots for millennia, and no doubt innovators have been trying just as long to invent both stronger rope and better knots. Yet the basic problem still remains: Every rope is weakened when its fibers are bent. Loading a knot with a large amount of weight creates a sheer force on the fibers; given enough force, the fibers break and the rope fails. Today’s
Author:
Publish date:
Updated on

Sailors have been tying knots for millennia, and no doubt innovators have been trying just as long to invent both stronger rope and better knots. Yet the basic problem still remains: Every rope is weakened when its fibers are bent. Loading a knot with a large amount of weight creates a sheer force on the fibers; given enough force, the fibers break and the rope fails.

Today’s double-braid polyester and nylon ropes tolerate sheer forces well, but ropes made of modern high-modulus fibers do not. While these fibers are stronger than steel (pound for pound), they cannot handle the forces created when a knot constricts on itself. With knots tied in them, high-modulus ropes are prone to break at loads far below their rated pull strength. Thus, unless these ropes are spliced instead of knotted, they have difficulty handling the loads generated by boats with powerful sailplans.

We tied five commonly used knots (the bowline, the figure 8, the round turn and two half hitches, the clove hitch with two half hitches, and the double fisherman’s knot) in three types of rope (1/2-inch double-braid nylon; 1/2-inch Sta-Set double-braid polyester; and 1/2-inch Endura Braid, a line with a 100 percent Spectra core and a polyester sheath) to determine exactly how much each rope’s strength is depleted by these knots. Pull tests were conducted over a course of two days at New England Ropes’s facility in Fall River, Massachusetts. We used a vertical-tensile tester, with constant rate of travel of one foot per minute and a maximum pulling force of 100,000 pounds. One end of the rope was captured by wrapping it around a 9-inch-diameter drum and then cleating it off, while the other end was tied to the machine’s business end with one of the test knots. None of the ropes were precycled (prestretched) prior to the pull test, as our intention was to see exactly how much force was required either for the knot to slip or for the rope to fail. Each knot was tested three times on each of the three ropes; the averages of the results are reported here. I tied each knot to reduce the statistical possibility that a different pair of hands might introduce a bias into the test.

Since the goal was to determine how much of a rope’s strength is lost with each type of knot tied in it, we recorded how much force was required for the knot to slip or for the rope to fail and then calculated what percentage of the rope’s strength this represented. We also tested the ropes using splices instead of knots to determine how much of each rope’s strength is preserved by splicing rather than knotting it. (Note: The ends of the spliced ropes were not whipped or heat-sealed.) New England Ropes supplied the actual total strength of each rope (our control group) based on pull tests they conducted previously; in these tests both ends of the ropes were wound around drums, secured with cleats, and pulled by the vertical-tensile tester until they failed. Here’s what we found.

1/2-inch double-braid nylon is a dynamic rope (it elongates under load) and is commonly used as docking line or for towing a dinghy. Its rated breaking strength is 10,800 pounds.

Bowline: 5,983 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 44.6%

Clove hitch with two half hitches: 7,021 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 35%

Round turn and two half hitches: 5,148 pounds

NOTE: This knot rolled open in all three tests before the rope snapped.

Percentage lost before the knot slipped: 52.33%

Figure 8: 6,227 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 42.33%

Double fisherman’s knot: 5,820 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 46.1%

Double-braid splice: 8,384 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost:

Sta-Set (double-braid polyester) is a static rope that is commonly used for sheets and halyards and as general-purpose cord; 1/2-inch Sta-Set’s rated breaking strength is 10,200 pounds.

Bowline: 5,617 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 44.9%

Clove hitch with two half hitches: 6,471 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 36.6%

Round turn and two half hitches: 6,492 pounds

NOTE: This knot rolled open in all three tests before the rope snapped.

Percentage lost before the knot slipped: 36.37%

Figure 8: 5,352 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 47.5%

Double fisherman’s knot: 5,250 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 48.5%

Double-braid splice: 8,934 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 12.4%

Endura braid (rope with a 100-percent Spectra core and a polyester cover) is a static rope used for sheets and halyards; 1/2-inch Endura Braid’s rated breaking strength is 19,300 pounds.

Bowline: 7,855 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 59.33%

Clove hitch with two half hitches: 7,448 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 61.44%

Round turn and two half hitches: 6,166 pounds

NOTE: This knot rolled open in all three tests before the rope snapped.
Percentage lost before the knot slipped: 68%

Figure 8: 7,713 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 60%

Double fisherman’s knot: 6,268 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 67.5%

Core-to-core splice: 20,594 pounds

Percentage of rope’s strength lost: 0%

Conclusions

As expected, tying a knot in any fiber substantially reduces its strength, so knowing how much of a rope’s strength is preserved by a particular knot is an important factor in selecting both a knot and rope for a particular job. The percentage of total strength preserved by each knot is similar when comparing the double-braid nylon and the Sta-Set (for example, a bowline tied in double-braid nylon preserved 55.4 percent of the rope’s strength, while a bowline tied in Sta-Set preserved 55.1 percent), but was significantly different for the Endura Braid (a bowline tied in Endura Braid preserved only 40.67 percent). Interestingly, each of the five knots had consistent strength-preservation percentages across the range of rope types, with the bowline, figure 8, and clove hitch with two half hitches emerging as the three strongest knots in this evaluation.

Conversely, splices made in the double-braid nylon and Sta-Set preserved 77.63 percent and 87.6 percent of total breaking strength, respectively, while spliced Endura braid preserved a whopping 106.73 percent of its total strength. As these tests show, it is imperative to splice, rather than knot, exotic-fiber ropes, regardless of the application. For instance, if a genoa sheet breaks, you can count on a prompt repeat failure if you replace the busted sheet and attach the new sheet with a bowline. While this might work in a light-air emergency, understand that the sheet, which is rated to 19,300 pounds, will fail at loads that are roughly 60 percent less than the brochure states.

Many thanks to Jeff Guiggey and Dave Goncalves of New England Ropes for helping conduct these tests. And special thanks to New England Ropes for use of their facility and for donating a generous number of ropes, all of which are now broken.

Related

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell. Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com The double range  Every skipper knows about ranging two objects in line to keep the boat on track in a cross-current. What’s less obvious is monitoring both sides of a gap such as a harbor entrance. ...read more

FamilyCruise

Bareboating on Puget Sound

Depending on where you are, Puget Sound can look no bigger than a mountainous version of the Intracoastal Waterway. That’s what I thought when I first laid eyes on it from the lighthouse at Mukilteo Park on a sunny day last July. Then I went to the top of the iconic Space Needle ...read more

Bali4point1

Boat Review: Bali 4.1

Coming fast on the heels of its predecessor, the Bali 4.0, the Bali 4.1 adds a number of improvements, many of them inspired by feedback from owners and charterers. She’s an evolution of a concept that has already proven popular and very many benefits from its builder’s ...read more

Headsail

Ask Sail: Silencing A Rattling Headsail

Q: Our Pearson 26 has a 110-percent jib that tends to rattle very noisily at the top hank. We only bought the old boat recently, but it must have been happening for a long time, since there’s a deep groove worn inside that bronze hank. The jib has an unusually large and wide ...read more

Alerion2048x

Alerion Yachts 33, the 90 Minute Get Away

Easy to sail, luxurious, and swift; the Alerion 33 is the solution to your busy life. The intuitive, simple rig design, easy set-up, and put-away mean there’s no need to wait for crew to enjoy a weekend, a day, or an hour out sailing. Her beauty and comfort are evident in the ...read more

anchor

Know how: Ground Tackle

Your ground tackle is like a relationship—the more you care for it, the longer it will last. So, how do you enhance the relationship? First up, think of the accommodations—a damp, salt-rich, often warm environment, just the kind of thing to encourage corrosion. What can be done? ...read more

DSC_7522

Boat Review: Beneteau Oceanis 46.1

The Beneteau sailboat line has long represented a kind of continuum, both in terms of the many models the company is offering at any given moment and over time. This does not, however, in any way diminish the quality of its individual boats. Just the opposite. Case in point: the ...read more