Ask Sail: Vibrating Engine Drive Trains

Last season I repowered my Catalina 30 with a new M3-20B Universal diesel engine. Its power curve was substantially different from the original engine, so I also changed the propeller. I ordered a new shaft, a new coupling half (fitted at the supplier) and a new prop.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Gerald Pritchett Lorain, Ohio

Q: Last season I repowered my Catalina 30 with a new M3-20B Universal diesel engine. Its power curve was substantially different from the original engine, so I also changed the propeller. I ordered a new shaft, a new coupling half (fitted at the supplier) and a new prop. Prior to the installation, a new cutless bearing was fitted. Alignment of the shaft coupling to the transmission coupling was kept well within 0.004in.

Now my boat only gains 0.3 knot of speed when engine speed is increased from 2,500 to 3,500 rpm. Maximum speed is 6.2 knots at 3,500 rpm, when calculations show it should be 6.7 knots.?I was expecting to have a nice smooth-running drive train. Instead there are vibrations at different levels throughout the operating range. At certain rpm levels, it sounds like someone is running a stick across a washboard. A thorough inspection was performed this fall and nothing seemed amiss.?Any suggestions for spring?

Nigel Calder Replies

 A: It sounds like you have harmonic vibrations at certain speeds. Vibration can absorb a lot of energy, which may be why you are not achieving your peak speed. It can also do significant damage. I am not an expert in this field, but here are some thoughts. If the vibration only occurs with the engine in gear, the problem is most likely in the drive train. If it is worse in forward or reverse gear, the problem is probably in the transmission itself. If the problem is in the drive train, but not in the transmission, typically the cause is a bent shaft, a loose or misaligned coupling or a damaged propeller. You may want to check all these again.

NigelCalder

Here’s another thought. If the propeller is not seated properly on its keyway, it could be a little off center. To check it, pull the propeller off, remove the key, slide the propeller up the shaft and mark where it seats. Then replace the key and make sure the propeller seats at the same point on the shaft. The propeller itself may be out of balance, so have it checked while it is off, or swap it for another.

If the vibration occurs out of gear, and if it is rhythmical, you probably have a fuel-injection problem. Given the fact that this is new installation, it may also be that the engine feet have not been adjusted properly. This can cause significant vibration and expensive damage. I once saw the crankshaft on a 2,000hp engine broken this way!

Got a question for our experts? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com

Related

pirate-marlin-logo

Pirate’s Cove Billfish Tournament

This Spring has felt a bit like a slow day of fishing but it’s almost time to time to Bait…and Switch. The Pirate’s Cove Billfish Tournaments offer something for every member of your crew. Exceptional fishing, fun times with family, old friends and new. Our run is short, our ...read more

Tusk.00_00_16_21.Still001

Tusk by Spyderco

Spyderco's Tusk knife combines a blade and marlinspike to create a multitool perfect for marine use. Made with corrosion resistant materials like titanium and LC200N steel, a nitrogen alloyed steel, and Spyderco-exclusive locking mechanisms, this knife is one of the toughest ...read more

IY11.98_fTaccola©DJI_0200

Italia 11.98 Performance-cruiser

This past winter, SAIL principal editor, Adam Cort, check out the new Italia Yachts’ new 11.98 performance-cruiser at the boot Dusseldorf show in German, and says he can attest to the fact it’s a boat more than worthy of the attention of North American sailors. Available in ...read more

01-LEAD-2017_IDALEWIS_0219

Racing: Doublehanded

I was born in 1955, and although I was a tad young to actually follow the first Observer Single-Handed Transatlantic Race, I grew up in the age of the pioneers of solo offshore sailing—Francis Chichester, Robin Knox-Johnson, Alec Rose, all Knighted for their singlehanded ...read more

newport-400c-updated

Spectra Watermakers

The world's quietest and most energy-efficient watermakers. Our product line ranges from hand operated desalinators that can make 6 gallons a day to our largest system that produces 20,000 gallons of fresh, potable water per day. Spectra Watermakers has the complete package: ...read more

CAPE-COD---Under-sails

Boat Review: Cape Cod

The concept of “daysailer” has grown ever broader over the years. These days the label can be pasted on a boat as small and simple as a Sunfish, as fancy as a 40-footer with a nice big cockpit and plenty of brightwork, or any number of concoctions in between. This Cape Cod ...read more

C-1002-600px

Sirius Signal

Be seen with the brightest SOS Distress Lights Available C-1002 Two Color Distress Light Flag & Whistle The Sirius Signal model C-1002 SOS eVDSD (electronic visual distress signal device) is the first product to be engineered to the new RTCM standard 13200.0 — accepted as ...read more