Ask Sail: Too Much Protection

How can I stop the galvanic action I suspect is causing the delignification of the surrounding wood? More zincs, or no zincs?
Author:
Publish date:
Updated on

Peter Karczmar, of Providence, Rhode Island, asks:

I have a wooden Mariner ketch with an Indel refrigerator that has a through-hull heat exchanger. I am seeing delignification of the wood around the through-hull, suggesting galvanic action. I’m having a similar problem with the wood around the bronze prop shaft. The boat spends nine months of the year on a mooring with only a handful of other boats in the area. Winter is spent in a slip at a marina plugged into shorepower.

I have a galvanic isolator, and the boat is not bonded. There are zincs on the prop, the through-hull for the heat exchanger, and on the keel. How can I stop the galvanic action I suspect is causing the delignification of the surrounding wood? More zincs, or no zincs?

Nigel Calder replies:

It sounds like the wood is suffering from alkali attack as a result of there being too much galvanic protection for your heat exchanger and prop shaft. This is surprising, given that you don’t seem to have much zinc deployed.

NigelCalder

If you can lay your hands on a silver chloride half cell and a good multimeter, you can test the level of protection. Put the meter in DC volts mode, plug the half cell into one side of the multimeter and hang it over the side in the water. Then put the other meter probe on the fitting to be tested (e.g., the heat exchanger or prop shaft). You will see a reading in millivolts (negative or positive, depending on how the probes are plugged into the meter). On a wooden boat this should not be above 550-600 millivolts. If it is higher, you have too much protection.

I would say in general a bronze prop shaft does not need a zinc, nor does the fridge heat exchanger if it is bronze, so try getting rid of those two zincs. However, the heat exchanger does need to be grounded inside the boat to battery negative, because of the copper refrigeration lines running into it. Without a grounding wire, if some fault in the fridge results in a short to the copper lines, the fault current could find a way back to the battery via the water, which would rapidly destroy the heat exchanger and could sink the boat.

Related

Dinghy Suggested CROP

Ask Sail: Dinghy Dilemma

DINGHY DILEMMA Q: We are in the throes of choosing a dinghy, and I would like to ask if you would recommend buying a RIB with a double-skinned hull rather than a single-skinned hull. Which provides better handling or stays drier? Also, aside from the heavier weight of a ...read more

Groupe Beneteau charging its boats in NEOLINE vessel

Transporting Sailboats Under Sail

Transporting sailboats under sail? That sounds like a cool concept, and it’s one that looks set to become reality in 2021 when shipping company Neoline brings its sailing cargo ships into service. Groupe Beneteau has committed to transporting boats between Europe and the United ...read more

01_vor120612_ross_0644

Sailing Master Ken Read

Images trigger memory. Preparing to interview the golden boy of American sailing, I thought I would find a picture that would show Ken Read at the peak of his sailing career, his heyday, to share and have a warm and fuzzy start to our conversation. It was a commanding image from ...read more

New-engine-being-lifted-over-stern

Know how: Replacing the Auxiliary Power System

One of the most complex tasks undertaken during Passion’s refit was the complete replacement of her auxiliary power system—engine, V-drive and fuel tanks. I needed more horsepower, which drove the need for more fuel capacity and a larger V-drive to handle the higher engine ...read more

20190614_131026

Kiwi Spirit Takes Line Honors in Bermuda

Mark Riley’s Farr 63 Kiwi Spirit secured line honors yesterday in the Marion to Bermuda race, finishing off St. David’s Lighthouse at 0227 local time. Francis Seldorff’s Kinship, a Baltic 52, was second in the 40-boat fleet, crossing the line at around 0500. With 18-year-old ...read more

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell. Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com No cracked skulls please Modern boats with aft bathing ladders offer a big advantage when it comes to rescuing crew who have fallen overboard. Not all casualties are basket cases unable to help ...read more

01-Lead-show

France’s Annual Multihull Show

If a boat show could be described as intimate, the annual Salon International du Multicoque in La Grande Motte, on France’s Mediterranean coast, is it. Held in the latter part of April, the multihulls-only in-water show is a boon for builders, because the people who attend come ...read more