Ask Sail: Solenoid Surgery

when first pushing the start button, I sometimes get no response. Releasing and pushing the button a couple of times finally engages the starter.
Author:
Updated:
Original:
solenoid-surgery

Gary Horvath of Grand River, Ohio, asks:

When I purchased my 1993 Hunter 33.5, I found the previous owner had installed a high-output alternator with an external regulator on the three-cylinder Yanmar engine. He also installed a simple pull switch near the engine’s control panel to manually energize the field voltage to the alternator. His practice was to start the engine, then engage the field to the alternator, I assume to control starting current by eliminating “in-rush” current on the un-energized field.

I had a hard time remembering to turn the switch on and off, so I eliminated it by tying the field to the load side of the ignition switch. Since then, when first pushing the start button, I sometimes get no response. Releasing and pushing the button a couple of times finally engages the starter. Interestingly, I had the same problem with my last boat, which had a single-cylinder Yanmar engine.

Is my theory of in-rush current to the alternator field pulling down the battery valid? I am thinking about reinstalling the pull switch or installing a time-delay relay that will energize the field after the engine reaches oil pressure. What do you think?

Nigel Calder replies:

NigelCalder

I don’t believe your alternator has anything to do with this. The in-rush current to the field winding is only a fraction of your cranking current. The contact points on your start button may be corroded and periodically making poor contact, but my guess is the points and contactor ring inside your solenoid on the starter are burned up. Periodically these burned-up parts are aligning and won’t transmit cranking current. Can you hear the solenoid on the starter clicking when you push the start button?

If you put a voltmeter across the terminals on the start button or across the two heavy-duty terminals on the solenoid, you should see around 12 volts until the button is pushed, then you should see close to zero volts. Test the start button switch first. If it continues to show 12 volts when the engine won’t crank, then the switch is the problem. If instead, the solenoid continues to show 12 volts when the engine won’t crank, then it most likely is the problem.

It’s easy to check the points on the solenoid: just disconnect the various wires and cables from the end of the solenoid, and then take out the screws holding the cap and pull the cap off. Be warned, though: there is a spring in here you don’t want to drop in the bilge! On many solenoids you can turn the points around and flip the ring over to get new contact surfaces.

Got a question for our experts? Email it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com

Related

Beneyteau-Excess12

Boat Review: Excess 12

Groupe Beneteau, builder of Lagoon catamarans, has introduced a new multihull line called Excess. The first of the boats to reach U.S. shores at the Annapolis boat show was the Excess 12, a 38ft 6in design based on the popular Lagoon 40. The thought process behind this new boat ...read more

Spindriftracing

Extreme Sailing: No Piece of Cake

It can be easy to take for granted the incredible performance of today’s most cutting-edge grand prix racing boats. The latest crop of full-foiling 75ft America’s Cup monohulls, for example, were all up on their foils and even successfully tacking within hours of their first ...read more

Solar-Dinghy-pump-photo

Gear: Solar Powered Dinghy Pump

Tired of forever finding your dinghy or open daysailer filled with water when you arrive to go sailing? For years, sailors and engineers have sought a solution to this seemingly eternal problem, and now it appears the folks at Sea Joule Marine may have finally found it in their ...read more

BestBoatPromo-03

Best Boats 2020

How’s this for a thought experiment: imagine setting a diminutive Tiwal 2 inflatable dinghy alongside a Catalina 545 cruiser? It would be hard to imagine two more different watercraft, and yet they are both still very much sailboats. They are also both winners in this year’s ...read more

Hanse-675

Video Tour: Hanse 675

This past fall at the Annapolis Sailboat show, we had a chance to catch up with Hanse’s  Maxim Neumann, who kindly provided us a tour of the company’s new flagship, the Hanse 675. An impressive, well-built production yacht that boldly ventures into maxi-yacht territory, the ...read more

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell. Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com Be thrifty with propane  If you like to cook on board, the propane tanks supplied as standard with many modern yachts won’t get you far. Whether we bake bread or not, the one thing we all do is boil ...read more