Ask Sail: Keel Attachments

Author:
Publish date:
Fiberglass alone is not sufficient to keep a fin keel securely attached

Fiberglass alone is not sufficient to keep a fin keel securely attached

Q: I have an early ‘70s Catalina 27. The keel bolts look pretty good. My question is, why not glass over the keel to bond to the hull rather than changing the bolts if, or when the bolts are too far gone? I haven’t seen anything on this, so could you discuss? Full-keels are permanent. It seems the fin keel could be made the same.

— Jon C. Anderson, Deer Island, OR

DON CASEY REPLIES

A little clarification here: it is not just fin keels that are bolted in place. Full-keel boats often have the keel bolted to the hull as well. When a keel is “permanent,” to use your description, the hull of the boat is molded with a keel cavity that is subsequently filled with a ballast material, generally lead.

In the fiberglass layup process, resins are applied on a schedule that allows each layer to bond to the previous one at the molecular level, creating essentially a homogeneous solid. However, once the resin has fully cured any additional layers will become attached almost entirely through mechanical adhesion, a far weaker bond.

In the case of a hull molded with a keel cavity, the keel and hull are one and the same, with the stresses widely distributed. When a keel is added externally, however, the stresses are concentrated at the joint, which means any attachment method must be up to resisting some pretty major stresses. It is not uncommon for the joint between the hull and an external keel to be “taped’’ over with fiberglass. However, the purpose here is not to support the keel, but rather to seal or fair the joint. Even then, the bond between the plastic resin and metal keel, often fails. Simply stated, as a method for attaching a metal keel to a hull, fiberglass is woefully inadequate for resisting the prying forces at work. External keels require a robust mechanical attachment, i.e., a set of stainless steel bolts.

Related

valleytrunk3

BVI Chartering in the Pandemic

The week before I flew out to the British Virgin Islands for a bareboat charter, I was having a few second thoughts. The islands had broken out of their Covid-enforced tourism hiatus in December, but the conditions of entry seemed a little stringent: a negative Covid test within ...read more

01-LEAD-windfarm

Sailing Amid Offshore Wind Farms

Here in Europe, the general feeling about green energy from offshore wind turbines has moved on after an initial surge of general skepticism. Concerns raised over cost, threats to seabirds, wind interference and the rest have to some extent been answered, and it’s hard to argue ...read more

LunaRossaPrada

VIDEO: Luna Rossa Wins the Prada Cup

The show has gone on despite last week's Covid panic in Auckland, and the "underdog" Italians are victorious. After being bested by INEOS Team UK in the round robin section, they seemed to have an uphill battle ahead of them going into the finals. However, the Italians have been ...read more

FB-BHM-Cuffe-2048x

Sail Black History Month Series: Paul Cuffe

Paul Cuffe was born on Cuttyhunk Island, Massachusetts, in 1759. His mother was a Native American woman named Ruth Moses, and his father was Kofi Slocum, a formerly enslaved man from the Ashanti Empire, located in modern-day Ghana. They had 10 children including Paul. His ...read more

Ryan-Finn

Point of SAIL: Ryan Finn on Solo-sailing a Proa Round Cape Horn

In this episode of Point of SAIL, Principal Editor Adam Cort talks with solo-sailor Ryan Finn, a veteran bluewater passagemaker looking to re-create the famed New York-to-San Francisco clipper aboard the 36ft proa, Jzerro. Although Finn was forced to abandon his first attempt ...read more

NewZealand

ACE Postpones Prada Cup

New covid cases in New Zealand have slammed the brakes on the selection series for the America’s Cup, forcing the postponement of Prada Cup racing and calling into question the remainder of the series. The America’s Cup Event (ACE) has put out a statement on their position as ...read more

LunaRossaLeads

VIDEO: Italians Lead in Prada Cup

After a dramatic first weekend of Prada Cup racing, Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli leads INEOS Team UK four wins to none. The magic number here seven: two more good days for the Italians or four nearly perfect days for the Brits. The Italians went into this series as the underdogs ...read more

03-Cockpit-Render

Balance 442 Performance-cruiser Design

A look at the thinking that went into the new Balance 442 performance-cruiser To say there’s a lot that goes into creating an all-new boat has got to be one of the world’s great understatements. And the job only becomes exponentially harder when boats get smaller, rather than ...read more