Ask SAIL: In-mast or Full-batten Main

My sailing buddy and I are thinking about moving to a bigger boat. I now have a 31ft Pearson with a full-batten main. It is a reasonably high-performance boat, and I love to sail it. My buddy wants to go to an in-mast furling mainsail. I would like some information on how much performance is lost when switching from a full-batten to in-mast main.
Author:
Publish date:
Social count:
0

Don Glynn of Westlake Village, California asks:

 In-mast furling: convenient, but there's a price to pay

In-mast furling: convenient, but there's a price to pay

My sailing buddy and I are thinking about moving to a bigger boat. I now have a 31ft Pearson with a full-batten main. It is a reasonably high-performance boat, and I love to sail it. My buddy wants to go to an in-mast furling mainsail. I would like some information on how much performance is lost when switching from a full-batten to in-mast main.

Win Fowler replies:

There would be a significant performance penalty, for two reasons. First, the mast and furling gear are substantially heavier than a conventional mast. Weight aloft adds to heeling and pitching moment, which will cause your boat to become more tender and more prone to hobby-horsing, which degrades performance. 

Second, an in-mast sail without battens has a hollow leech and narrow head angle that makes the sail a much less efficient airfoil. The net deficit in performance for an in-mast furling main, according to PHRF New England, is six seconds a mile. This is a fairly arbitrary number that I think underestimates the actual penalty for most boats. It’s true the hollow-leech problem can be ameliorated through the use of vertical battens, but we frequently hear stories of in-mast sails getting stuck partially furled, and this problem is much more common in sails with vertical battens.

Still, there is no question that in-mast furling, when working properly, takes much of the effort out of handling a mainsail. If you are willing to give up some performance, it may be for you.

Got a question for our experts? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.com

Related

01-Hanse_Emotion_6

Hanse’s E-Motion Electric Rudder Drive

When news that Hanse Yachts had launched a new form of electric-powered yacht first broke in the winter of 2016, it was widely reported. After all, Hanse is one of the world’s biggest builders of sailing boats, so this had the feeling of a breakthrough to it.After nearly a year, ...read more

TOTW_PromoSite

SAIL's Tip of the Week

Presented by Vetus-Maxwell.Got a tip? Send it to sailmail@sailmagazine.comDefusing the Run It’s been said with justification that gentlemen don’t boast about how windy it was, but the shape of my ensign in the photo will give well-informed readers a fair idea. They will also ...read more

01b-Over-Loch-Scavig

Cruising Across the North Sea

Conventional wisdom says sleeping in the V-berth while offshore is a bad idea. It can be like a diabolical amusement ride that tosses a sailor to and fro, inducing stomach-churning weightlessness. And yet, here I am, nestled in the tilted corner created by my berth and the ...read more

GG17-SAONA47-DX0796

Boat Review: Fountaine Pajot Saona 47

Here’s a riddle: What is less than 50ft long, has two hulls, three big cabins and four decks? Answer: The Fountaine Pajot Saona 47. In fact, it may even be five levels if you count the large engine rooms. This boat is a “space craft” in every sense of the word.DESIGN & ...read more

RichardBennettMIDNIGHT-RAMBLER3249x202

Storm Sails: Do you Need Them?

Many sailors embarking on ocean passages will take along the obligatory storm jib and trysail, with the vague idea that they may come in handy. Few sailors, however, have a real understanding of how and when to set them.It doesn’t help matters when we hear from seasoned sailors ...read more