Comparing Design Ratios

When buying a boat, consider how its ratios compare with those of similar boats in its category.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Given the infinite number of variables involved, making any kind of objective comparison between two different sailboat designs might, at first, seem impossible. However, with the help of design ratios, you can not only compare and contrast different designs, but get a pretty good idea, sight unseen, as to how a boat is going to perform under sail.

The Beneteau Sense 46 is a typical modern cruising boat, with an SA/D of 19, a Ballast Ratio of 28 percent and a D/L of 159. Note that this particular D/L was determined using the light-ship displacement. The half-load figure would have been higher.

The Beneteau Sense 46 is a typical modern cruising boat, with an SA/D of 19, a Ballast Ratio of 28 percent and a D/L of 159. Note that this particular D/L was determined using the light-ship displacement. The half-load figure would have been higher.

The first of these, the Displacement-Length Ratio (D/L) is a nondimensional expression of how heavy a boat is relative to its waterline length. A D/L ratio is calculated by dividing a boat’s displacement in long tons (2,240 pounds) by one one-hundredth of the waterline length (in feet) cubed. Because the displacement in long tons can be expressed as a volume (cubic feet of seawater), and since length-cubed is also volumetric, the result of the D/L formula is nondimensional, i.e., it is no longer tied to a particular physical size.

formular-1

This means the D/L can be used to compare the relative "heaviness" of boats no matter their size. For example, a boat with a 25-foot waterline and one with a 50-foot waterline are equally heavy relative to their respective waterline lengths if they have the same D/L ratio. The relative heaviness of boats is often categorized as follows:

formular-2

These gradations are applicable to current designs, which tend more toward reduced overhangs and longer waterlines than earlier boats. Most sailboat designs of the 1930s through the 1960s had D/Ls (as they are often referred to) above 300, but with their long overhangs their sailing length was increased as they heeled, resulting in “effective” D/Ls at speeds that were well below their calculated values.

The significance of the displacement-length ratio is that the lighter a boat is relative to its waterline length, the higher its speed potential, especially when in displacement mode. If there is less water to push aside, wavemaking drag is reduced. Some ultralight-displacement boats, or ULDBs, are light enough to plane just like a powerboat, in which case a low D/L gives some indication how quickly and easily a design will transition out of displacement mode. (Although hull shape is also important.)

With a Ballast Ratio of 40 percent, an SA/D 25 and a D/L of 136, the Tartan 101 represents another step up the performance ladder.

With a Ballast Ratio of 40 percent, an SA/D 25 and a D/L of 136, the Tartan 101 represents another step up the performance ladder.

While at first it might seem desirable to always have as low a D/L as possible, as in most aspects of yacht design there are trade-offs. In general, the lower the D/L, the less comfortable the boat’s motion will be in a seaway and the more sensitive the boat is to overloading.

Another important design parameter is the Sail Area-Displacement Ratio (SA/D), another nondimensional calculation that expresses the relationship between a boat’s sail area and its displacement. Traditionally, it is calculated by dividing the nominal sail area in square feet by the boat’s displacement in cubic feet to the two-thirds power.

formular-3

In this case, displacement is converted from pounds to cubic feet by dividing it by 64, the weight of a cubic foot of seawater. The standard displacement used by most designers for comparative purposes is the half-load displacement, calculated with the boat equipped for sailing with the crew and half the consumables (provisions, water, fuel, supplies) on board.

The nominal sail area is calculated as the sum of the foretriangle area (one-half the base, or J dimension, multiplied by the height, or I dimension) and the mainsail area (one-half the foot, or E dimension, multiplied by the hoist, or P dimension). It's important to note, however, that naval architects (and marine journalists) are increasingly using actual sail areas for mainsails, in particular, because the nominal area fails to account for the larger roaches often flown on modern rigs.

The SA/D is also nondimensional because sail area in square feet is divided by a displacement term that has been converted from cubic to square feet. This mathematical manipulation results in a parameter that again is independent of boat size. Therefore, a 30-footer with a SA/D of 20 will have just as powerful a rig as a 60-footer with the same SA/D.

SailPlans

In general terms, a boat having a sail area-displacement ratio under 15 would be considered under-canvased; values above 15 would indicate reasonably good performance; and anything above 18 to 20 suggests relatively high performance, provided the boat has sufficient stability and a low enough displacement-length ratio to take advantage of its abundant sail area.

The SA/D is analogous to an automobile’s horsepower-to-weight ratio, with sail area being a measure of power, and displacement being indicative of wavemaking drag. The principal components of drag are friction and wavemaking; since wavemaking increases disproportionally with speed, the SA/D is indicative of performance in moderate- to heavy-air conditions.

It is important when comparing the SA/Ds for different boats to be certain that the sail area and displacement values are measured in the same way for each boat. In SAIL's New Sailboat Review, we typically calculate ratios using the mainsail and 100% foretriangle area.

On occasion a boatbuilder may publish sail areas and displacements that are larger and lower than nominal so as to maximize a boat’s SA/D ratio in the interest of making appear to be higher performance. This is done by quoting the area of an overlapping genoa, or in the case of displacement, publishing the light-ship weight of the boat as shipped from the builder rather than the half-load displacement.

Finally, there is the Ballast Ratio, or the amount of ballast a design is carrying. Unlike the first two ratio, this one requires no fancy conversions of units: simply divide the weight of the ballast by the half-load displacement, and then multiply by 100. The higher the number, the greater the righting moment, i.e. the greater to the ability to resist heeling.

With a 50 percent ballast ratio, a D/L of 75 and an eye-popping SA/D of 47, the McConaghy 38 is a racer in the truest sense of the word. Note that with a light-ship displacement of just 7,055 pounds, crew weight is also a factor in terms of the actual performance of this boat.

With a 50 percent ballast ratio, a D/L of 75 and an eye-popping SA/D of 47, the McConaghy 38 is a racer in the truest sense of the word. Note that with a light-ship displacement of just 7,055 pounds, crew weight is also a factor in terms of the actual performance of this boat.

Typically, a ballast ratio of 40 or more translates into a stiffer, more powerful boat that will be better able to stand up to the wind. However, it's important to be aware that ballast placement also plays an important role in righting moment: for example, the same weight of internal ballast will provide far less righting moment than at the very tip of a deep fin keel. Therefore, ballast ratios are somewhat less determinant than the first two.

While righting moment if obviously important to good sailing performance, this is another area in which is it possible to have too much of a good thing. Specifically, a boat with an aggressive righting moment will have a faster, more aggressive motion in a seaway, which can be hard on crews. If you're only spending an afternoon racing around the buoys, then comfort may not be especially important. However, "sea-kindliness" as it's called, can make all the difference in the world on a long passage.

Related

Waypoint.image.cd

Say No To Waypoints

Ever since they first appeared in my navigational toolbox decades ago I have been wary of waypoints. They certainly do seem helpful, these electronic flags we plant in the ether to guide us to where we want to go. But I noticed early on they also tend to distort our perception. ...read more

Lead-shutterstock_429247

A Cruise up Florida’s St. Johns River

The chart showed 45ft of vertical clearance, and I knew the boat should be able to pass under the bridge. Still, there was that nagging voice in my head that wouldn’t let me be. “What if your air draft calculations were wrong?” it said. “And if you’re just a little too high the ...read more

pic00

Installing a Helm Pod

Our 1987 Pearson project boat came with an elderly but functioning Raymarine chartplotter, located belowdecks at the nav station. Since I usually sail solo or doublehanded, it was of little use down there—it needed to be near the helm. When I decided to update the plotter along ...read more

Panamerican

Pan American Game Success

Team USA’s young sailors went to the quadrennial Pan-American Games in Lima, Peru this summer with high hopes, and returned with a good haul of medals—two Golds, three Silvers, and two Bronze. Gold medals went to Ernesto Rodriguez and Hallie Schiffman (Mixed Snipe) and Riley ...read more

190916-AC75

U.S. Team Launches First America’s Cup Boat

Fast forward to around 2:25 to see the boat in action. First day out and already doing full-foiling gybes: not too shabby! Hard on the heels of the unveiling of New Zealand’s first AC75, the New York Yacht Club’s American Magic team has now launched its first America’s Cup ...read more

GGTobCaysHorseshoeColors

Picking a Charter Destination

Picking a destination should reflect the interests of your group, says People often ask about my favorite charter destination, and invariably, I sidestep the question with one of my own: “Well, what do you want to do on your vacation?” Most often I hear an incredulous, “Why, ...read more

sinking

Waterlines: Chasing Leaks on Boats

Chasing leaks on boats is a time-honored obsession. Rule number one in all galaxies of the nautical universe through all of nautical history has always been the same: keep the water on the outside. When water somehow finds its way inside and you don’t know where it’s coming ...read more

BestBoatNominees2020-Promo

Best Boats Nominees 2020

Bring on the monohulls! In a world increasingly given over to multihull sailing, SAIL magazine’s “Best Boats” class of 2020 brings with it a strong new group of keelboats, including everything from luxury cruisers nipping at the heels of their mega-yacht brethren to a number of ...read more