Riders on the Storm
To sail to windward in heavy weather, you need a flat-cut headsail. A heavily reefed roller genoa typically is anything but flat. The draft in the sail migrates aft as the sail is reefed, and you end up with a baggy sail that presses the boat down and wont allow it to point.
One solution is to drop your genoa and hoist a storm jib. Another is to set a storm jib on a detachable inner forestay. But both these options are usually too much hassle for a typical coastal cruiser, who rarely runs into severe conditions and then only briefly. Enter ATN Inc. and Banner Bay Marine: both companies market storm jibs that can be set over rolled-up headsails. Simply furl your headsail, rig either of these storm jibs, hoist and trim. The boat should immediately benefit from a more balanced helm and greatly reduced power.
Last summer SAIL tested Banner Bays STORM-BAG and ATNs Gale Sail to get a feel for how easy it is to set and stow these systems. Heres what we learned.
The ATN Gale Sail is a fairly straightforward storm sail made from bombproof 8.5- or 9.5-oz. Dacron, depending on the size of the boat. What sets it apart from a typical storm jib is the bright red sleeve sewn into the luff. To rig the sail, you simply attach the tack pennant to a shackle below the furling drum and, beginning at the foot, wrap the sleeve around the furled headsail, clipping the piston hanks to their corresponding grommets as you go. Once the hanks are secured, clip a halyard to the head of the sail, run the sheets and hoist. Ideally you should have a pair of dedicated sheets already bent on to the clew. We also found its a good idea to secure the genoa sheets to the base of the forestay with a sail tie so they wont get in the way.
In admittedly benign conditions, we had no trouble hoisting, trimming or flying the Gale Sail; however, we did find it was a little tricky to attach the piston hanks to their grommets, a process that requires two hands. Factor in a heaving foredeck, cold fingers and plenty of wind and water, and this task could prove difficult. This was the sails only real drawback. Everything else was a breeze.
Banner Bays STORM-BAG uses a clever integral packaging system to stow, prep and hoist the sail. Each STORM-BAG sail folds into a bright yellow case that resembles two giant cockpit cushions sewn together at one endthink of a walletwith bits of hardware sticking out.
In actuality, the case contains two identically cut storm jibs that are stitched together at the luff and share a single head loop and tack pennant. To rig the sail, you simply carry the STORM-BAG forward and wrap it around the headstay. The two clews are then clipped together with the shackle at the end of a pair of dedicated sheets that are included in the kit. A halyard is clipped to the nylon head loop, and the tack pennant is secured. The sheets are led aft to the requisite headsail cars and winches. (You will, of course, have already figured out the correct lead positions.) Once solid sheet tension is exerted on the bagit can take some effortthe Velcro closures on the case rip open and the two-ply day-glow orange sail can be hoisted. The case dangles from the foot of the sail.
Setting and using the sail was a snap. We found that the sail could be rigged and hoisted with minimal time spent on the foredeck. Tacking the sail was no problem and trimming also proved easy. Because the sail is actually two sails, each made of slightly less robust cloth than a single storm jib, there was some audible chatter between the two pieces of sailcloth, especially along the leech. Air pressure keeps the two sails pressed against each other, but chafe could be a problem over time. Also, it would be interesting to see what happens if the plies separate when running downwind in a strong breeze.
My concerns about the STORM-BAG began when we lowered the sail. After each use, the sail must be tightly flaked and packed into both sides of the STORM-BAG, which would be a challenge on a small deck in even a dead calm. Throw in subsiding storm conditions and the job would be impossible.
This is a substantial drawback. Re-hoisting the sail without its clever packaging would be harder than hoisting a standard storm jib due to the fact that youd have to contend with twice as much sail area. We ended up cramming the sail belowdecks, where it nearly filled our 34-footers saloon. Back on solid ground with ample room to work, we were ableafter some coaxingto flake the sail into its case using the manufacturers reference marks.
We tried both sails in a gentle 8-knot breeze, which made setting them much easier than it would have been in 30-plus knots of wind. When its blowing hard you want to spend as little time as possible on the foredeck. We found the STORM-BAG to be the easier sail to rig, thanks to its clever case. For most families who mainly daysail or make short passages, this is likely the best solution. The Gale Sail shines on longer passages and for serious offshore work. It is not as easy to rig as the STORM-BAG, but you dont need a large work space to re-flake the sail, and it takes up considerably less room.
Whichever sail you use, go out on a calm dayas we didand practice hoisting it with your regular crew. Youll be happy you did once the wind pipes up and the waves turn ugly.